929 Fairview Lake Road Stillwater, NJ 07875 | Daily 11AM-9PM
The sugar shack
Closed for the season
MADE TO ORDER
SUGAR SHACK ICE CREAM PIES
Enjoy our ice cream during the holidays!
Thanksgiving and Christmas we sell ice cream pies!
We offer different flavors depending on the holiday.
Enjoy our delicious ice cream in a graham cracker crust!
To Place an order fill out the form below,
send us a message on social media, or give us a call!
Follow us on Facebook and Instagram!
Thanksgiving ice cream pie order cut off November 20, 2025.
Thanksgiving Ice Cream Pie Order Form
(1-3) $15 each (4+) $14 each
ENJOY OUR ICE CREAM AT HOME WITH OUR PINTS
Available April-October
Call for details or to place your order
ICE CREAM CAKES
ENJOY OUR ICE CREAM FOR YOUR SPECIAL OCCASION WITH OUR DELICIOUS ICE CREAM CAKES!
Bunt style ice cream cake with sprinkles or chocolate crunch in the center!! Enjoy extra toppings with every slice!
Available April-October
Call for details or to place your order
No icing only ice cream!
Any available flavor can be turned into a delicious ice cream cake! In the center is chocolate fudge and chocolate crunch for an added taste with every bite.